Guide · critical illness cover and income protection
Critical illness cover or income protection: which is right for you?
Both are there for you when you're ill, in different ways. Critical illness cover pays a lump sum if you're diagnosed with a condition listed in your policy. Income protection pays you a monthly income if illness or injury stops you doing your job.
An adviser calls you with real prices from the insurers.
Why it's worth it
Two ways to keep your life on track
A lump sum when it matters
Critical illness cover can clear the mortgage, cover a year or two of income, or pay for changes at home. You decide.
An income that keeps coming
Income protection pays every month while you're off work, so the bills keep getting paid. You can claim more than once.
Priced around your budget
We price both, on their own and together, so you can see the choice in pounds and pick what suits you.
Side by side
How the two compare
| Critical illness cover | Income protection | |
|---|---|---|
| What it's there for | A diagnosis of one of the conditions listed in your policy. Cancer, heart attack and stroke are on every list, with many others. | Almost any illness or injury that stops you doing your job, from a broken leg to a bad back. |
| How it's paid | One lump sum. You decide what it's for. | A monthly income, usually up to 60–65% of your earnings, depending on the insurer. |
| When it starts | Once your claim is accepted. | After the waiting period you choose: day one or one week with some insurers, or 4, 8, 13, 26 or 52 weeks. |
| How long it pays | One payment, to use however you need. | Every month until you're back at work or the payment period you chose ends. You can claim more than once. |
| What sets the price | Your age, smoking, health, the amount, the length of the policy, and whether you pick an insurer's basic or fuller version. | Your age, job, smoking, health, the monthly amount, the waiting period and how long each claim can pay. |
| Tax on the payout | Under current rules, a policy you pay for yourself normally pays out free of income tax. Your accountant can confirm. | |
| Ideal for | Someone who'd want a lump sum to clear a mortgage or debt, cover a year or two of income, or pay for changes at home. | Someone whose bills are paid from what they earn, with little or no sick pay, such as the self-employed. |
In real life
Where each one helps
A few everyday examples show how the two work together.
| What happens | Critical illness cover | Income protection |
|---|---|---|
| You break your leg and can't work for three months | This one's for income protection. | Pays you for the time you're off after your waiting period. |
| You're signed off for months with a bad back | This one's for income protection. | Pays you every month after your waiting period. |
| You have a heart attack covered by your policy, and you're back at work in six weeks | Pays you the lump sum. | Pays too, if your waiting period is shorter than six weeks. |
Better together
Many people have both
Why both work well
The lump sum can clear a debt or pay for changes at home after a serious diagnosis. The monthly income keeps the bills paid through the illnesses and injuries that keep you off work.
Starting with one
It depends on your sick pay, your savings and who relies on your income. With no sick pay, income protection helps with more of the things that could stop you working. With good sick pay or savings, a lump sum may matter more. We price both and you choose.
Making both fit your budget
Income protection costs less with a longer waiting period, a smaller monthly amount, or a two-year limit on each claim. Critical illness cover costs less with a smaller lump sum or an insurer's basic version. Your adviser shows you each option.
Questions people ask
Straight answers
Can I have both?
Yes, and many people do. Some take a smaller amount of each rather than a large amount of one. We'll show you the price of each on its own and together.
Will income protection pay if I get cancer or have a heart attack?
Yes, if it keeps you off work beyond your waiting period. Income protection doesn't work from a list: it pays a monthly income while illness or injury stops you doing your job.
I get sick pay from work. Do I still need either?
Income protection can be set to start when your sick pay runs out, and a longer waiting period costs less. Sick pay doesn't give you a lump sum, which is where critical illness cover comes in.
I'm a company director. Is it different for me?
It can be. Your company can own and pay for the income protection, which is called executive income protection. We'll price the personal and company versions side by side.
What if I've had health problems?
You may still get cover. Insurers treat the same condition differently, which is where comparing them helps. Don't send health details through this website: your adviser asks what's needed on the call.
What does the advice cost?
There's no fee for our advice. The insurer you choose pays us commission, which is included in your premium. We'll explain this before you buy.
Your adviser
One adviser, from first call to cover in place
They'll show you the numbers, tell you which we'd recommend, and stay with you for the life of your policy. No call centre, no scripts, no being passed around.
See both priced side by side
Your adviser asks about your work, your sick pay and what you'd want the money to do, then prices both. No fee for our advice, no obligation. Many people have both, and we'll help you find the right mix.